An organ donor process called normothermic regional perforation (NRP) is raising ethical concerns among organ transplant doctors. The procedure involves slitting the throat of the donor while they are still alive to assure that they do not re-animate in the comatose state they are kept in medically. This is done to prevent their organs from degrading before they can be used.
Lauris Kaldjian, MD, Ph.D., director of the bioethics and humanities program at the University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, is calling out this unethical practice. He claimed, “NRP represents a technologically elaborate attempt to refashion definitions of death to maximize the number and quality of transplanted organs. It both depends on and violates the circulatory definition of death and arguably employs iatrogenic (doctor-induced) brain death.”
Slitting organ donors’ necks will not increase trust in transplant system– www.lifesitenews.com
News Source
EXCERPT:
The U.S. organ transplant system is now recommending that surgeons slit the blood vessels supplying organ donors’ brains as a safety measure to keep the donors from waking up when doctors resuscitate the remainder of their bodies for organ procurement.
The new guidelines apply to a type of organ retrieval known as Normothermic Regional Perfusion (NRP). NRP organ donors are not brain dead, but they either have a poor prognosis or have decided that their quality of life is unacceptable. Their deaths are planned to occur in such a way as to allow them to donate their organs.
The NRP process begins by withdrawing medical support and letting the donor’s heart stop. At this point, death is declared under the Uniform Determination of Death Act’s (UDDA) circulatory-respiratory standard: the irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions.
But because waiting for the heart to stop beating is often a slow process, the organs can begin to degrade from a lack of oxygen. This hypoxic interval can make organs like the heart unsuitable for transplantation. If these organs could somehow be resuscitated, the number of transplantable organs could be increased. But if blood flow to the brain should occur during this resuscitation, the patient might wake up.
Therefore, in order to procure a donor heart, NRP surgery traditionally begins with clamping off the blood flow to the patient’s brain. This is meant to make the patient intentionally brain dead and prevent them from waking up when the rest of the body is resuscitated. Also, by clamping the arteries that feed the brain, the legal category of death switches to the UDDA’s neurologic standard: the irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain including the brain stem. This way, doctors are legally covered when the person is resuscitated from the neck down and their heart starts beating again.

